Once Upon a Mattress' Michael Urie Says Sutton Foster Is His 'Gumby Girlfriend' | 半岛体育

半岛体育

How Did I Get Here Once Upon a Mattress' Michael Urie Says Sutton Foster Is His 'Gumby Girlfriend'

The stage and screen star is currently playing Prince Dauntless in the Broadway transfer of the 1959 musical.

Michael Urie Graphic by Vi Dang

Ever since he burst forth as Vanessa Williams' devious assistant Marc St. James on the ABC series Ugly Betty, Michael Urie has enjoyed a career that moves easily between stage and screen.

The Texas native, back on stage in the acclaimed revival of Once Upon a Mattress at the Hudson Theatre, made his Main Stem debut as a replacement in the role of Bud Frump in the 2011 revival of How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. He has subsequently been seen on Broadway in the 2018 revival of Torch Song, Bess Wohl's Grand Horizons, Douglas LyonsChicken & Biscuits, and the 2023 revival of Spamalot.

It was the 2013 Off-Broadway premiere of Jonathan Tolins鈥� Buyer & Cellar, however, where Urie was able to display the true breadth of his comedic talents, playing Alex More, a struggling actor who takes a job working in the mall beneath Barbra Streisand's Malibu home. For his work in the solo show, Urie wound up winning the Drama Desk Award, Clarence Derwent Award, the Lucille Lortel Award, and LA Drama Critics Award as well as nominations from the Drama League and Outer Critics Circle.

He is now bringing those comedic gifts, as well as a heartwarming na茂vety, to the role of Prince Dauntless, who is searching for a perfect wife despite the interference of his overbearing mother, in the aforementioned Mattress revival. The production, first seen at New York City Center as part of the long-running Encores! series, is directed by Lear deBessonet and also stars Sutton Foster, Nikki Ren茅e Daniels, Ana Gasteyer, Will Chase, Daniel Breaker, Brooks Ashmanskas, and more.

Urie, whose numerous screen credits also include Younger, Modern Family, The Good Wife, Workaholics, Hot in Cleveland, Single All the Way, Maestro, Swan Song, and Summoning Sylvia, will be seen in the second season of AppleTV+鈥檚 award-winning dramedy series Shrinking, which returns October 16. Later this year, he will appear alongside Michael Keaton, Mila Kunis, and Andie MacDowell in the new film Goodrich. The actor, producer, director, and host is also the co-founder of NYC鈥檚 Pride Plays, which celebrates and elevates LGBTQIA+ voices in the theatre.

In the interview below for the 半岛体育 series How Did I Get Here鈥攕potlighting not only actors, but directors, designers, musicians, and others who work on and off the stage to create the magic that is live theatre鈥擴rie shares that time he smoked marijuana for his day job, and why he'd do Buyer & Cellar again.

Ana Gasteyer and Michael Urie in Once Upon a Mattress Joan Marcus

Where did you train/study?
Michael Urie: The Juilliard School of Drama! I also had incredible teachers in high school and community college.

Was there a teacher who was particularly impactful/helpful? What made this instructor stand out?
I was a very shy kid and found the middle school drama department super intimidating and for the cool kids. I wanted to get involved but didn鈥檛 have the guts. I was obsessed with movies and really wanted to pursue show business, so when I got to high school, I figured I鈥檇 need to get over my shyness. First day of theatre class, however, I found not only was the teacher on maternity leave, the students were completely unserious about theatre. I expressed this to the substitute, and she put me on the phone with the regular teacher, Mrs. Colvin. We spoke for a while, and she put me in the advanced class with students who were much more serious. She told me it impressed her that I had the courage to ask for what I want and told me to never lose that instinct. To this day, some of my favorite jobs were the result of simply asking to be considered. In this business, sometimes it can feel like enthusiasm isn鈥檛 鈥渃ool,鈥� but I think tenacity and hard work are vital components to an artist鈥檚 staying power.

What has it been like revisiting Prince Dauntless for Broadway and with several new cast members? Do you have a favorite moment in the show for him?
Playing this show in the intimate Hudson Theatre is so cozy (City Center is stunning but massive)鈥攊t kind of feels like 1,000 people all crawling into bed together to hear a story. The new cast members are all wonderful: I鈥檓 loving playing with my brilliant new mom, Ana Gasteyer; Brooks Ashmanskas is the funniest person I鈥檝e ever met; Daniel Breaker has been my hero since he was a year above me at Juilliard; and Will Chase is totally dashing as Sir Harry. Lear deBessonet has encouraged me to explore the ways in which Dauntless grows up during the course of the show, and it鈥檚 become a very rewarding character arc!

Michael Urie, Sutton Foster, and company in Once Upon a Mattress Joan Marcus

What have you discovered about physical comedy working with Sutton Foster?
You mean my Gumby girlfriend?! She鈥檚 the most inventive and fearless scene partner I鈥檝e ever had鈥攈er onstage joy is an extension of her offstage kindness鈥攚hen we are out there together, it feels like we share a brain. And dancing? She is so good at it, it鈥檚 like she鈥檚 dancing for both of us鈥攕he can tell if I don鈥檛 know what鈥檚 next, and she鈥檒l subtly steer me where I鈥檓 supposed to go. I feel safer out there with her than I have with anyone ever.

Your Broadway career has been a consistent mix of plays and musicals. What is the challenge/reward of performing in a musical versus a drama or comedy?
In a musical, we are always finding pains and bruises we can鈥檛 explain. When singing, there are certain notes that have to be hit. Speaking is different鈥攊t鈥檚 much easier to adapt if your voice is tired or raspy for whatever reason. So, the physical demands are certainly greater in a musical, but the rewards are sweeter. Firstly, you鈥檙e surrounded by fabulous music all the time鈥攚hether it鈥檚 this lush Mary Rodgers score, the hilarious and sweet sounds of Spamalot, or the timeless bops by the Four Seasons, these are great tunes to have in your head all day. Plus, the people鈥n a musical there are so many more people around鈥攎usicians, sound techs, stage hands, wardrobe folks, dancers, and singers.

Do you have a dream stage role?
I鈥檝e been very lucky to play a lot of my dream roles (Hamlet, Prior Walter, Mozart) plus some roles I didn鈥檛 know were dream roles until I got them (Arnold Beckoff, Prince Dauntless). There is one that I鈥檝e wanted to play as long as I鈥檝e known about theatre, and it鈥檚 Tom Wingfield in The Glass Menagerie. I鈥檝e had a lot of great moms as an actor, so imagining who could play Amanda Wingfield is dreamy. Judith Light? Jean Smart? Charles Busch?

Michael Rosen and Michael Urie in Torch Song Joan Marcus

Can you share one of your favorite stage mishaps?
One night in Torch Song, a prop orange rolled off the stage and into the audience. I texted Harvey Fierstein about it, and he wrote back, 鈥淭hat always happens in prop shows.鈥� I鈥檇 never heard that term before, 鈥減rop shows,鈥� and I thought, 鈥淚 learned a new theatre term from Harvey Fierstein, now I鈥檓 in the big time!鈥�

Once, a woman took the long way to the restroom during a performance of Buyer & Cellar and had to walk in front of the stage right beneath me the exact moment I, as Barbra Streisand, was pantomiming pushing a cup of yogurt upside down into a vat of sprinkles. I said, as Barbra, 鈥淥h, watch out for the sprinkles!鈥� 

What do you consider your big break?
Ugly Betty, for sure. I played Vanessa Williams鈥� assistant, and the plan was for her to be such a demanding boss she鈥檇 have a new assistant every week. But Vanessa liked me, and so our chemistry bloomed, and by the end of the pilot, they鈥檇 decided to keep me.

What is the most memorable day job you ever had?
I once did a medical research study on the effects of medical marijuana. I鈥檇 go to a hospital, smoke a little, and take these computerized tests. Then I鈥檇 have to wait around until the effects wore off and munch on hospital food.

Is there a person or people you most respect in your field and why?
I think Bill Irwin is the theatre maker I most look up to鈥攆rom musical comedy to Albee to Chekhov to Beckett, to say nothing of his out-and-out clowning, he鈥檚 just a genius.

Tell me about a job/opportunity you really wanted but didn鈥檛 get. How did you get over that disappointment?
The hardest losses are the ones that feel like they were yours to lose鈥� I was in the workshop of How to Succeed with Daniel Radcliffe and afterwards offered the part of Bud Frump. Six months later, one of the rights holders asked to see me do it, so I had to go back in and audition. I lost the part that day. It was definitely the hardest single rejection I've ever experienced because I鈥檇 been counting on it happening for so long, and it was basically mine to lose. Eighteen months later, they asked me to come in as a replacement鈥攕o the story has a happy ending! 

But, I鈥檓 very grateful for that low. Our highs and lows are (I think) the most important moments because they eventually cancel each other out, and you can find an emotional middle ground to navigate it all.

Michael Urie in Buyer & Cellar Photo by Sandra Coudert

What advice would you give your younger self or anyone starting out?
I think it鈥檚 impossible for one not to compare themselves or their careers to others, but it really is silly to do so. No two artists have ever had the same trajectory. There鈥檚 no one right or wrong way to do this crazy business, and we all spend too much time worrying about how we compare when there鈥檚 just no real way to compare.

What do you wish you knew starting out that you know now?
That this business is a marathon, not a race. That the comparisons I am making about myself are mine and mine alone: Everyone else is busy making their own comparisons about themselves and not actually thinking about me. That 鈥渨ho you know鈥� is real, but those connections might take years to bear fruit.

What is your proudest achievement as an actor?
My second biggest break and greatest gift has to be getting to perform Jonathan Tolins鈥� brilliant solo play, Buyer & Cellar. It鈥檚 so rare to find a role that is so good and original and fun, and then to have it be a hit... I did it over 600 times (including in our apartment on Broadway.com as a benefit for BC/EFA during the pandemic lockdown) and would do it again in a heartbeat.

Photos: Opening Night of Once Upon a Mattress

 
Today鈥檚 Most Popular News:
 X

Blocking belongs
on the stage,
not on websites.

Our website is made possible by
displaying online advertisements to our visitors.

Please consider supporting us by
whitelisting playbill.com with your ad blocker.
Thank you!