The Plymouth Theatre opened in 1917. Designed by Herbert J. Krapp, the Plymouth joined the Booth, Broadhurst and Shubert Theatres to solidify the Shubert family dominance on a full block of W. 44th and 45th Streets. In 2005, the theatre was renamed for Gerald Schoenfeld, the chairman of the Shubert Organization.
| Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre | 2005 |
| Plymouth Theatre | 1917 |
| Jan 1, 1973 - | "The Shubert Organization, Inc." | |
| Jun 8, 1946 - Jan 1, 1973 | Select Operating Corporation | |
| Apr 7, 1933 - Jun 8, 1946 | Select Operating Corporation | Theatre Owner |
| Jan 1, 1924 - Apr 7, 1933 | Shubert Theatre Corporation | Theatre Owner |
| Oct 10, 1917 - Jan 1, 1924 | Messrs. Shubert (Lee and J. J.) | Theatre Owner |
| Oct 10, 1917 - Jun 8, 1946 | Arthur Hopkins | Theatre Operator |
